Versions Compared

Key

  • This line was added.
  • This line was removed.
  • Formatting was changed.

...

Motivating Synchronized Release

...

CVD

...

process

...

discussions

...

tend

...

to

...

focus

...

on

...

the

...

handling

...

of

...

individual

...

vulnerability

...

cases

...

rather

...

than

...

the

...

social

...

fabric

...

surrounding

...

vulnerability

...

coordination

...

we

...

construct

...

over

...

time.

...

Shifting

...

away

...

from

...

the

...

individual

...

units

...

of

...

work

...

to

...

the

...

social

...

structure

...

can

...

suggest

...

a

...

way

...

out

...

of

...

some

...

of

...

the

...

more

...

contentious

...

points

...

in

...

any

...

given

...

case.

...



We

...

previously

...

described

...

the

...

multiparty

...

delay

...

problem.

...

Game

...

theory

...

provides

...

us

...

with

...

the

...

prisoners'

...

dilemma

...

as

...

model

...

for

...

thinking

...

about

...

this

...

concern.

...

The

...

main

...

takeaway

...

from

...

research

...

into

...

the

...

prisoners'

...

dilemma

...

is

...

that

...

by

...

shifting

...

one's

...

perspective

...

to

...

considering

...

a

...

repeated

...

game,

...

it's

...

possible

...

to

...

find

...

better

...

solutions

...

than

...

would

...

be

...

possible

...

in

...

a

...

one-shot

...

game

...

with

...

no

...

history.

...

The

...

recognition

...

that

...

it's

...

a

...

repeated

...

game

...

leads

...

to

...

improved

...

cooperation

...

among

...

players

...

who

...

would

...

otherwise

...

be

...

motivated

...

to

...

act

...

solely

...

in

...

their

...

own

...

self-interest

...

in

...

each

...

round

...

[1].

...



One

...

approach

...

we've

...

found

...

to

...

work

...

is

...

to

...

remind

...

the

...

parties

...

involved

...

that

...

this

...

will

...

likely

...

not

...

be

...

the

...

last

...

multiparty

...

vulnerability

...

coordination

...

effort

...

in

...

which

...

they

...

find

...

themselves.

...

A

...

vendor

...

that

...

repeatedly

...

releases

...

early

...

will

...

likely

...

get

...

left

...

out

...

of

...

future

...

coordination

...

efforts.

...

Because

...

of

...

this,

...

the

...

quicker

...

vendors

...

might

...

be

...

motivated

...

to

...

delay

...

so

...

they

...

get

...

the

...

vulnerability

...

information

...

the

...

next

...

time.

...

Perhaps

...

most

...

important

...

for

...

those

...

wanting

...

to

...

release

...

early

...

is

...

to

...

remember

...

that

...

this

...

is

...

a

...

repeated

...

game;

...

you

...

might

...

be

...

first

...

one

...

ready

...

to

...

publish

...

this

...

time

...

but

...

that

...

may

...

not

...

always

...

be

...

the

...

case.

...

Consideration

...

for

...

the

...

other

...

parties

...

involved

...

in

...

any

...

given

...

case

...

can

...

yield

...

better

...

outcomes

...

in

...

the

...

long

...

run.

...



In

...

the

...

end,

...

everyone

...

benefits

...

from

...

vendors

...

improving

...

their

...

vulnerability

...

response

...

processes,

...

so

...

helping

...

the

...

laggards

...

become

...

more

...

efficient

...

can

...

sometimes

...

become

...

a

...

secondary

...

goal

...

of

...

the

...

coordination

...

process.

References

  1. R. M. Axelrod, The Evolution of Cooperation, Revised ed., Basic books, 2006.